We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.
You can find these eggs in different ocean biomes as they are laid by turtles on the beach. Home Banners Turtle egg Minecraft Banner. Check out other cool remixes by Murky Muffin and Tynker's community. The range of detection is a taxicab distance of 23 blocks away horizontally and 3 blocks vertically (counted from the block the mob is standing on) on Java Edition. Have tey been stomped? Turtles when done breeding will not lay an egg, even if I made a newborn an adult and tried to breed that one. To use a spawn egg, right click it on the ground. Also, they will seek out the eggs from 17 blocks away from the egg (Not counting the block the egg is on) Turtle Eggs are randomly dropped by Carbonemys. This Minecraft tutorial explains how to breed turtles with screenshots and step-by-step instructions. MCPE-36466 Turtle eggs not cracking just spawn in when I tame turtles. Determines how close an egg is to hatching; starts at 0 and is randomly incremented. Eggs crack over time and hatch after cracking three times. Crafting Used to craft 1 item The Turtle Egg is one of the Eggs in ARK: Survival Evolved. Browse Servers Collections Time Machine . Turtle eggs are laid in clutches of 1–4 eggs. The eggs always spawn in a cluster where each cluster can have up to 4 eggs. Minecraft Forum; Minecraft: Java Edition; Discussion; drowned not attracted to turtle egg? This egg will hatch into a baby turtle (only at night) after going through all stages of growth/development. Edit and deploy with 1-click on Tynker's Minecraft servers. Expected behavior The zombie pigmans in the Nether must attack the turtle eggs. If you are having trouble finding turtles eggs, you can breed turtles to create a nest of turtle eggs (or clutch of turtle eggs). The different numbers of turtle eggs that can fit in one block. Turtles in Minecraft are considered a common passive mob that moves on both land and in water. If you still cannot find any turtle comes to you, using a spawn egg can be a solution. … Though eggs cannot be trampled by non-living entities like arrows, they can be trampled by armor stands. Community . Each cluster can have up to 4 eggs. In Minecraft, it takes patience and a few tricks, but you can hatch turtle eggs to make cute little baby turtles. The eggs will hatch only when laid in a specific sand type. Resolved; Activity. When I shoot one from that place, they aggro me and fall. Each cluster can have up to 4 eggs. Turtle Eggs Are Not Hatching in Minecraft? Check out other cool remixes by Murky Muffin and Tynker's community. And there are no babies, no nothing. Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. Turtle eggs can be obtained in the inventory using tools with the Silk Touch enchantment. Search Planet Minecraft. How to Breed Turtles in Minecraft. Stackable Even if I fill it with solid block in a straight path to it, they don't aggro the egg. BobbyJoe255 shared this idea. Another important thing to note is that they only hatch at night. It grows in oceans, rivers, and lakes where it can be picked up if you break it using … Eggs cannot be trampled by a crouch-walking (or "sneaking") player. I've got some pigmen on a platform in the nether with a turtle egg in the center of a 5x5 area with trapdoors. cluck422. View User Profile View Posts Send Message Out of the Water; Join Date: 8/22/2020 Posts: 5 Information about the Turtle Spawn Egg item from Minecraft, including its item ID, spawn commands and more. When you wear a turtle shell, you will also be able to craft a turtle master potion. Your goal is to knock other players down into layers below you, all the while surviving the slow collapse of the turtle eggs that you stand on. Turtle Eggs will crack for the first time. Minecraft Wiki is a Fandom Gaming Community. The main egg (largest and placed first) is a 5x7x5 "pixel" box but is textured as if it was 4x7x4. The eggs also have a tendency to attract evil zombies so make sure you have ample protection around the eggs. The bug. It is one of the best steps that can help you to start to get the turtle as a pet. Sea Turtle Eggs hatch after an unknown period of time, producing baby Turtles. Cowmaflage turtle! Transparency How to make turtle eggs open in Minecraft? Thank you for visiting MinecraftSkins.com - Skindex, the source for Minecraft skins Taking them elsewhere will not work. More turtle eggs than normal can now be placed in one stack by aiming at adjacent. Turtle eggs can be trampled by living entities (players, mobs, livestock, etc.) I have lit up the zone and put a fence around them. The 3 stages a turtle egg goes through before it hatches: plain, slightly cracked, and cracked. To get the turtle easily, you need to summon them using a cheat on your game. They progress through a number (3?) After two sea turtles are fed seagrass, one of them will burrow into nearby sand and lay 1-4 eggs. This is vanilla 1.13. If you still cannot find any turtle comes to you, using a spawn egg can be a solution. minecraft turtle egg hatch time. credit goes to kittyeooo. Remix and deploy turtle spawn egg. Hello, I propose an easter egg idea for the 1.13: This idea is to rename a turtle "Flash" and it would have a custom skin as in the picture. Minecraft . But with a turtle egg there they just stand around doing nothing. A turtle egg is a block that can hatch, producing a baby turtle. Mobs such as zombies, husks, skeletons, wolves, or ocelots will try to destroy turtle eggs, so players may have to guard them to ensure they will hatch. Bedrock Edition has the following data values: Issues relating to "Turtle Egg" are maintained on the bug tracker. 1.13 (Snapshot 18w07a) 1 Obtaining 2 Usage 3 Trivia 4 References Sea Turtle eggs are only obtainable using a Silk Touch Enchanted Pickaxe. I have been collecting turtle eggs with Silk Touch, and placing them in a beach near my house. Turtle eggs spawn in \"clusters\" (or \"nests\") along shorelines. In order to get Seagrass, you must either use Shears on the grass that grows underwater or kill turtles. Renewable Turtles will only breed on the beach they spawn on. 1 Mechanics 2 Trivia 3 Gallery 4 Video 5 References Sea turtles spawn on beaches in various ocean biomes. Any ... Name a turtle "egg" not case sensitive and it will have eggs on its back! Their home beach as well. First Appearance Turtle eggs on hatch if laid in the sand It takes 3 to 10 Minecraft nights for the eggs to hatch depending on the tick speed The eggs will only hatch on the sand and during the night Feeding 10 Seagrass to a baby turtle grows it into an adult instantly [1] They can hatch to produce additional turtles. Turtles have many enemies in their first days of life, so you will have to protect the beach from enemies. You can farm turtle eggs in Minecraft by breeding turtles. Mcpe 35045 Turtles Dont Lay Eggs Jira. Sea Turtle Eggs are Blocks that were added in Update 1.5. Turtle eggs have a very low chance of cracking during random ticks during the day (1/500 chance), however, they are guaranteed to crack during random ticks between 3:36 am and 4:33 am in-game. All Zombie variants are trying to destroy Turtle Eggs. The block model for minecraft:turtle_egg is textured in a way not consistent with other blocks, with the pixels not aligning to the 16x16 grid despite not having any rotation. Players can also destroy the eggs by jumping on them. After a few minutes, the eggs will emit a cracking sound and hatch into baby turtles. Theylay turtle eggs1 which can hatch to produce additional sea turtles.2 Sea turtles can be bred with seagrass. Invite friends to see your creations and custom mods. If you are running the game on any java edition platform (PC/Mac) 1.13, Pocket Edition (PE) 1.5.0 or Xbox 360, then you are at the right place. They are the third eggs added overall. Residents of the SMP7 wild may make arrangements with me in a PM to have purchases mailed or otherwise delivered. In Minecraft, baby, turtles are usually the smallest mobs half the size of endermite. Minecraft Turtle Egg - With Custom Cursor browser extension you can change your cursor to a custom one from cursor collection or upload your own cursor So for anyone wondering, it seems to be limited to zombies, zombie villagers, and zombie pigmen from what I tested. Turtle Eggs only hatch during the night. Breaking a cracked turtle egg with a Silk Touch tool resets the growth stage when the egg is placed on a different block. Aqua turtle! Turtle Egg Official Minecraft Wiki. As of November 2020, the Minecraft wiki's documentation of mechanics relating to turtles and turtle eggs was incomplete. When jumping on it or breaking it with a tool that has not the Silk Touch enchantment on it, it will drop nothing. A Turtle laying an egg Due to the high amount of time it takes for eggs to hatch in Minecraft, it’s a good idea to protect them. Many players don’t truly understand the hatching mechanics in the game. To get the turtle easily, you need to summon them using a cheat on your game. Hatching turtle eggs in Minecraft can take a little while so don’t be discouraged. All types of Zombies except for Zombie Horses will trample and destroy Sea Turtle Eggs. Turtles will naturally lay turtle eggs in the game along the edge of the sand in the Beach biome. Get them close On average, an egg will hatch in 4-5 nights. The turtle will lay up to 4 eggs. A turtle egg[a] is a block that hatches one or more baby turtles. These eggs will hatch into baby turtles. See hatching mechanics below. The detection range is 10 blocks away horizontally and 2 blocks vertically on Bedrock Edition. October 31, 2019 02:21 Up to 4 turtle eggs can be placed in one block and slowly hatch into turtles.
How Long Does It Take for Turtle Eggs to Hatch in Minecraft? Tools PMCSkin3D Banners . minecraft:turtle_egg All crafted Pets are created using Eggs. Report issues there. The turtle will lay up to 4 eggs. Mobs, such as zombies, may also try to destroy turtle eggs. Step 6: Rabbits/Bunnies. Turtle Egg Turtles were introduced in Update Aquatic (1.13) and spawn naturally within water. And have you placed sand. Log In. The turtle eggs have been observed to hatch faster during the night hours. I sometimes stay a night near the fence just in case they hatch and to defend them from drowned. In this tutorial, we have built a wall of sand around our turtles to keep them nearby. Turtle eggs are laid by turtles on the beaches of various ocean biomes. Sea Turtle Eggs are the second placeable eggs added to Minecraft after the Dragon Egg. Beginning at sundown they have a chance to hatch throughout the night increasing in percentages significantly at or after 3/4 of the night completed.
Minecraft Bedrock Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. When a falling block such as an anvil or sand block is dropped onto an egg, the falling block is dropped and turned into an item leaving the egg is unharmed. See Also : How to Tame a Ocelot in Minecraft. Eggs do not appear to progress toward hatching if the player is not awake and within 128 blocks of the egg so the chunk is loaded and receives random ticks. Roughly 95% of eggs will hatch during this nighttime window. 64 Turtle egg clusters now use correct cullface arguments, with the exception of four turtle eggs, which still renders a redundant face. ... is duplicated by. Minecraft Turtle Egg - With Custom Cursor browser extension you can change your cursor to a custom one from cursor collection or upload your own cursor After a few minutes, the eggs will emit a cracking sound and hatch into baby turtles. Once the turtle is done digging, it will lay different sizes of turtle eggs on the ground. Once they are done, they just go in the water and swim in circles for eternity. The detection range of hostile mobs toward turtle eggs, Graph of simulation results showing how long it takes turtle eggs to hatch. As a result, their turtle … Before delving deeper on how to make turtle eggs hatch in Minecraft, it’s wise to know the versions of Minecraft where the turtle egg is available. Turtle Egg is a block added by Minecraft.When two Turtles have been fed with Seagrass, one of them will place a Turtle Egg.Up to four eggs can be placed in one block. Update Aquatic Now 1 13 All Information We Have So Far. Tool Used https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Stone_dig1.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Stone_dig2.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Stone_dig3.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Stone_dig4.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Stone_hit1.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Stone_hit2.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Stone_hit3.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Stone_hit4.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Stone_hit5.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Stone_hit6.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Turtle_egg_hatch1.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Turtle_egg_hatch2.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Turtle_egg_hatch3.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Turtle_egg_crack1.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Turtle_egg_crack2.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Turtle_egg_crack3.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Turtle_egg_crack4.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Turtle_egg_crack5.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Turtle_egg_break1.ogg, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/File:Turtle_egg_break2.ogg, https://github.com/jeremy-rifkin/MC-Turtle-Mechanics, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Turtle_Egg?oldid=1772086, Pages using DynamicPageList dplreplace parser function. This is vanilla 1.13. November 3, 2020 | No Comments. These eggs vary in size and are usually covered in green spots. In Minecraft, you can breed turtles and make a cute little baby turtle from a turtle egg. After a few minutes, the eggs will emit a cracking sound and hatch into baby sea turtles. But the eggs dissapear. Edit and deploy with 1-click on Tynker's Minecraft servers. Reference source code generated by MCP-Reborn (1.16.3). First, you need to find turtle eggs. 3. Today I will be messing around with turtle eggs in Minecraft Turtle eggs are laid by Turtles on the beaches of various Ocean biomes. A sea turtle is a passive underwater mob that can spawn in ocean biomes. 1 Obtaining 2 Usage 2.1 Bridge Egg 2.2 Chicken Head 2.3 Enchanted Egg 2.4 Stone Platform There are a few different ways to obtain eggs, with varying difficulty: Wait for the chickens in The Barn to drop eggs. I've got some pigmen on a platform in the nether with a turtle egg in the center of a 5x5 area with trapdoors. Eggs are also capable of supporting lanterns hanging under them.[1]. It is one of the best steps that can help you to start to get the turtle … If a player breaks a turtle egg before it hatches, no turtle will emerge. Remix and deploy turtle spawn egg. I sometimes stay a night near the fence just in case they hatch and to defend them from drowned. Turtle eggs only hatch if on sand(not red sand). Have tey been stomped? It cannot be obtained in Vanilla MC. The turtles will feed on seagrass and will breed. The eggs also have a tendency to attract evil zombies so make sure you have ample protection around the eggs. Therefor, it’s a good idea to surround the area in fences and torches to ensure hostile mobs don’t spawn. Though turtle eggs can be placed on any block, they only hatch on sand blocks. They can hatch to produce additional turtles.These eggs can be found in various sizes and are covered in green spots. Sea Turtle eggs are only obtainable using a Silk Touch Enchanted Pickaxe. Knife turtle! Turtle eggs hatch on sand and red sand. Minecraft . 1. Dark mode. After two sea turtles are fed seagrass, one of them will burrow into nearby sand and lay 1-4 eggs. While you can't tame a dolphin in Minecraft, you can feed it some food and it will indeed do something great for you. This turtle spawn egg Minecraft Items was remixed by Murky Muffin. Let's explore how to breed turtles. A player damaging an egg before it can hatch will not spawn any baby turtle out of it. Sea Turtle Eggs are the second placeable eggs added to Minecraft after the Dragon Egg. Up to 4 turtle eggs can be placed onto 1 block. Collect seagrass. search. How To Hatch A Turtle Egg Minecraft 1 13 Update Youtube. The typical time taken for four turtle eggs to hatch if you do not indulge in any enhancement procedure would be three days. Hatching turtle eggs in Minecraft can take a little while so don’t be discouraged. I have lit up the zone and put a fence around them. Better not hit him! I've tested that 1.13 to 1.16 will crash. If you are having trouble finding turtles eggs, you can breed turtles to create a nest of turtle eggs (or clutch of turtle eggs). How Long Does It Take Sea Turtle Eggs To Hatch. Your goal is to knock other players down into layers below you, all the while surviving the slow collapse of the turtle eggs that you stand on. Turtle eggs do not require a supporting block below and unlike dragon eggs are not affected by gravity. If a player breaks a turtle egg before it hatches, no turtle will emerge. Information about the Turtle Egg block from Minecraft, including its item ID, spawn commands, block states and more. Make it so using bone meal on a turtle egg will make it hatch faster. The egg will break without dropping anything when pushed by a piston or falling on to it, or a block affected by gravity falls onto it. that fall onto or stand on top of them. Zombies and their variants seek out and trample turtle eggs that have 2 blocks of air above them unless mobGriefing is false. Description The zombie pigmans in the Nether do not attack the turtle eggs. How To Breed Turtles In Minecraft. An entity falling onto an egg has a 1/3 chance of trampling the egg and an entity standing on top of an egg has a 1/100 chance per tick of trampling the egg. https://twitter.com/_LadyAgnes/status/953259234770194433, https://minecraft.net/en-us/article/new-mob-approaches, https://minecraft.fandom.com/wiki/Turtle_Egg?oldid=211442. [3] Turtle eggs spawn in "clusters" (or "nests") along shorelines. Another important thing to note is that they only hatch at night. If the player or mobs other than the Turtle walks over an egg, it will be destroyed. Even if I fill it with solid block in a straight path to it, they don't aggro the egg. Minecraft lets you farm turtle eggs by breeding the turtles. Turtle Hatching & Turtle Shell Helmet • The Minecraft Survival Guide (Tutorial Lets Play) [Part 106] by Admin Added 1 year ago 45 Views / 0 Likes This tutorial will show you how to breed and hatch turtles, and how to craft a Turtle Shell helmet f But the eggs dissapear. Turtle eggs can be farmed by breeding turtles. Now you will have two adult turtles and a nest of turtle eggs (or clutch of turtle eggs). They are also the second to produce baby Mobs, after normal Eggs. Sea turtles can be bred with seagrass. This causes the top to be stretched in both directions and the sides to be stretched sideways. People. When a player in Survival or Adventure Game-mode is nearby, the zombie prefers to attack the player rather than trampling the turtle egg. See Also : How to Tame a Ocelot in Minecraft. This turtle spawn egg Minecraft Items was remixed by Murky Muffin. However using Silk Touch on a Turtle Egg and then hatching the egg on your own man made beach is a viable option and will allow you to breed turtles at your home base or wherever else you want. Export. When two turtles close to each other are fed seagrass, one of them will burrow into nearby sand and lay 1-4 eggs. Sea turtle eggs take forever to hatch. Eggs are laid by Chickens, and are used in various recipes. October 30, 2019 19:21. Minecraft Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. They hatch significantly faster at nighttime. Make it so using bone meal on a turtle egg will make it hatch faster. This spawn egg can be used to spawn a turtle in Minecraft. Turtle Egg Spleef is a new take on the Spleef format of mini games. I have done some digging through the code to try to understand and document the mechanics better. This is a roughly 48-second window for the player. Technical Name How To Get Turtle Eggs In Minecraft. A large number of mobs on a large number of turtle eggs will cause the game to crash in an uncertain time.It seems that the game thinks that the air is the turtle egg, but the data value of the turtle egg cannot be found, causing the game to crash. Once they are bred, one of them will return to the beach and lay eggs in a few seconds. Other than fish, turtles are water-friendly, unlike other passive mobs. How to breed turtles in Minecraft, from finding wild turtles to hatching turtle eggs and what you can use the little turtles for. by Autumn Fish Minecraft's Bedrock Edition added 3,000 new species of fish, Drowned Zombies, Bubble Columns, and even Sea Turtles! The more cracks the egg has, the closer it is t… The Turtle egg was contributed by Anonymous on today. Cet oeuf est fragile: si on tape dessus, si on saute dessus, si on le pousse avec un piston, ou si on reste dessus trop longtemps il se cassera.Le seul moyen pour le ramasser et le déplacer est d'utiliser l'enchantement silk touch. Watch this video as we show you how to breed turtles and hatch turtle eggs in the new Aquatic Update (Java Edition 1.13)! Turtle Egg Spleef is a new take on the Spleef format of mini games. Some turtles have been found as far as a mile from the nearest water source. On the third crack, baby turtles will begin moving around. Minecraft Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. [2]These eggs can be found in various sizes and are covered in green spots. The number of eggs in a nest, called a clutch, varies by species. Can you put a lead on a dolphin in Minecraft? SMP7 /v +turtle Thread will be bumped periodically with stock updates, so watch out for those! I have been collecting turtle eggs with Silk Touch, and placing them in a beach near my house. When a multi-egg block hatches, all eggs hatch simultaneously. #1 Sep 7, 2020. cluck422. BobbyJoe255 shared this idea. Flammable Find Turtle Eggs. Search Search all Forums Search this Forum Search this Thread Tools Jump to Forum drowned not attracted to turtle egg? Determines how close an egg is to hatching; starts at no cracks and is randomly incremented. Content Maps Skins Mobs Texture Packs Data Packs Mods Blogs . After a few minutes, the eggs will emit a cracking sound and hatch into baby turtles. This page was last edited on 30 November 2020, at 04:36. Once you feed the turtles, hearts will appear over their heads, and they'll turn toward each other. If a player breaks a turtle egg before it hatches, no turtle will emerge. We welcome feedback from beta testers on that fix. You should note that turtles are quite different from other animals; therefore, it has a distinct breeding cooldown. Afterward, one turtle will burrow under the sand and lay one to four turtle eggs. After two turtles are bred with seagrass, one of them travels back to its home beach, digs in the sand, and lays an egg block with 1–4 eggs after several seconds. Also an attempt to blend in with the water? Either case, we will be giving a few tips on how you can fix turtle eggs not hatching in Minecraft. Turtle eggs won't hatch: i waited more than 5 in game days (1hour) but they won't hatch! Turtle eggs are laid by turtles on the beaches of various ocean biomes. Turtle eggs can be placed similarly to normal solid blocks, and slowly hatch into turtles. Eggs hatch significantly faster at nighttime. When they produce and feed on seagrass, they will be able to lay 1 to 4 eggs on the nearby sand. If a player breaks a turtle egg before it hatches, no sea turtle will emerge. But with a turtle egg there they just stand around doing nothing. When jumping on it or breaking it with a tool that has not the Silk Touch enchantment on it, it will drop nothing. Sea Turtle Eggs are the second placeable eggs added to Minecraft after the Dragon Egg. Minecraft (Bedrock codebase) MCPE-36095; Turtle eggs won't hatch. Item The turtle will lay four eggs in the sand by digging into it. Invite friends to see your creations and custom mods. L'oeuf est pondu par les tortues après leur accouplement. If you are having trouble finding a turtle, you can summon a turtle using a cheat or you can use a spawn egg. If broken without the enchantment, pushed by a piston, a gravity-affected block falls into its space, or a player or item falls onto it from a higher block, the egg breaks without dropping anything. All Zombie variants are trying to destroy Turtle Eggs. Luminosity Mar 2, 2018 - This Minecraft tutorial explains how to hatch turtle eggs with screenshots and step-by-step instructions. Il est créé sur la plage de naissance de la tortue qui le pond. This one is great! And there are no babies, no nothing. Turtle Eggs are a block that hatch after some time to produce a baby turtle. Home Minecraft Texture Packs Turtles+++ Minecraft Texture Pack. Turtle eggs cannot be trampled by bats, however, they can be trampled by other flying mobs such as bees. 90% of eggs hatch in 7 nights or less.[2]. Eggs in a multi-egg block are trampled one at a time until no eggs remain. Login; or; Sign up; Dark mode. When I shoot one from that place, they aggro me and fall.
Turtle Eggs only hatch during the night. Tutorials Turtle Farming Official Minecraft Wiki. A fix is announced in the 1.16.0.57 beta changelog. (Eggs do not appear to progress towards hatching if the player is not awake and within 50+ blocks.) Let's explore how to hatch a turtle egg. It can be obtained if broken with a silk touch pickaxe. They can be eatenor used to make Regular Kibble for taming Anglerfish, Ankylosaurus, Baryonyx, Beelzebufo, Carbonemys, Carnotaurus, Dimetrodon, Diplodocus, Doedicurus, Gigantopithecus, Ichthyornis, Kaprosuchus, Kentrosaurus, Lymantria, … Jun 4, 2020 - Minecraft Turtle Egg - With Custom Cursor browser extension you can change your cursor to a custom one from cursor collection or upload your own cursor Search Planet Minecraft. Block Once your turtle lays eggs, you will be able to breed it once again. Turtle Egg is a block added by Minecraft.When two Turtles have been fed with Seagrass, one of them will place a Turtle Egg.Up to four eggs can be placed in one block.
Front Desk Resume Skills, Black-eyed Susan Vine Yellow Leaves, Ath-m40x - Bal-m40x, Short Best Man Speeches, Uml To Code Java, University Of California, Irvine Acceptance Rate, Quillback Spelunky 2, Kennedy Krieger Ranking, Southern Pescatarian Recipes,
Leave a Reply