We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.
And same to the genre, Ito is tapping into something very basic to human nature by playing into our fear of not only what is unknown, but what may never be known or explained. I think its obvious she will stay quiet when to comes to the last scene. (Ex. I've seen people say this is both lazy as well as pointless, because the characters had no impact on the story whatsoever. Suichi mentioned how spirals trapped things naturally because of their shape, so that theme was extended to everything including the mechanics used in the writing, and I think it's pretty brilliant. With Boyd Holbrook, Cleopatra Coleman, Bokeem Woodbine, Michael C. Hall. Under the Shadow (2016), Iranian horror. The point would be to keep the viewer in the shadows by stopping there. I think the point of the main characters was to give the reader people they could identify with and share a journey with. Every so often, it would make its presence known to the townspeople in order to rebuild itself. After his death, the Other Kane steps into view, but with little more than a 5 O'clock shadow. Jing somehow survived against all odds his encounter with General Yang. It was ment to be a hopeless ending. Under the Shadow has already enjoyed amazing reviews, and yes, this is yet another one – but one more honest than many others! For me, this ending is very fitting. The real story is just too unbelievable, as even if she unmasks the assassin, the real commander is too disfigured to be recognizable. It’s a huge mess at the end, but now Jing is able to emerge from the bloodbath an independent man with his own agency moving forward. And also being in a room with a shadow (whose mother was just killed), and a known traitor without any guards is just plain dumb. Even though I wanted more explanations, and the idealist in me wanted some sense of resolution, after thinking about the story more, I came to the realization that all that would make it worse. Them sleeping together was for her the last moment they could be together. This is why I hate and love cosmic horror. The main characters are just vehicles to explore the nightmare-town. We went to see Shadow this weekend, and enjoyed it. Hair isn't living tissue, but it still grows. Furthermore, neither they nor the readers found any detailed answers for why the spiral would stop being dormant every so often in order to rebuild itself. The spiral was something bigger than them and humanity in general, so making the characters helpless felt right. To quote Stephen King: "Nightmare's exist outside of logic, and there's little fun to be had in explanations; they're antithetical to the poetry of fear. Just saw this and am blown away. The door to the palace == secret door in the wall. There are some theories I have read online (or thought myself) about the spiral. What is the significance of the pouch? Perhaps to reinforce to the audience that the Commander’s wife is the only reason he is following through with this suicidal plan. But with that completion, all who were part of the town would perish with the spiral. Kane can't fully explain this to the aliens on his own. His Dark Materials season 2 ending explained: Unpicking that epic finale 3h ago The Christmas double issue - available now Find out more and see our cover come to life Plus the commander already has friends in court (the other generals love him and were wishing for the day he could take power). I hope this makes sense... New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Highly suspenseful and creepy with rich cultural context. So maybe Jing gave the pouch back to her to comfort her, to remind her of the man for whom she had once shown compassion. But now, figuratively speaking, she is the commander looking out at Jing. Indeed, Mad Sweeney was a minor character who only appeared in two scenes of the book It like sleeped all the time and occationally woke up, and all that happened was just the unintentional influence off the spiral, thing that was likely so powerfull only its presense and slow waking made people and nature alike loose it, but for it it was just an ordinary day and it didnt even know/ couldnt know /didnt care about the people and its own influence on them. Experience what it feels like when you don't know. Also I didnt think the spiral needed humans. Shadowhunters took fans to hell and back (a few times) during Monday’s 2.5-hour series finale, which concluded with one last twist that was anything but mundane. Sam is an admitted failure at whatever he was trying to do and he does resemble the failed actor when he's sitting on the couch with the gun in his hand at the end of the film. She clutches it as she looks through the crack in the door. Some cosmic entity known as the spiral had existed in the town for who knows how long. Also how was the asasssin (real commander) able to stand upright? In a horror story, the victim keeps asking why, but there can be no explanation, and there shouldn't be one. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. So while we come face to face with a huge looming shadow of cosmic horror, beyond that shadow there is an even greater shadow of the brain's hard-wiredness toward narrative resolution. Which is when you're unsure what causes it or whether something was wrong in the first place. Its like I think it would have been stupid for Hellstar remina to end in humanitys victory, since if that kinda thing happened Irl (yikes) we wouldnt win, cause we dont always gey happy endings, or explanations, because we dont controll all off everything. If I just took the story as literal, I'd still find plenty of substance. The commander's wife has just witnessed the shadow murder both her husband and the king. ... done. Shadow anticipated this move and stabbed Commander first. I get just as much of a chill contemplating this second shadow, which is by its nature finite and finitizing, and yet it is more "boundless" or greater than the shadow of cosmic horror, which is by its nature infinite, and infinitizing. Man THANK YOU for linking this to that early one-liner. The way I saw it, the story was fairly clear. IMO, the ending where she peeks through the door cracks can have different meanings, and it depends how you understood the plot. It is my favorite kind of horror right next to the other sub-genre called "uncertainty horror". She is also fully aware that the shadow has manipulated the bodies in a way that appears as though her husband (a masked assassin) has murdered the king, leaving the shadow in a position to take power. Directed by Jim Mickle. For one, the spiral used them to rebuild itself (the row houses). The Shadow Wars endgame explained - how to unlock Shadow of War's true ending. Then she finds out in a passing reference that his mother has been killed. Its interesting to consider your view. The main story may be over, then, but that's not the end of the game - … The troopers seen at the end of the episode might be Dark Troopers or Shadow Troopers, according to Games Radar. Under the Shadow is perhaps the most unexpected horror movie in many years.It’s intense and psychological, but also very much a supernatural story. The wife now will become a trapped person in this facade (if she continues with it) or faces trial and possibly execution for being related and involved in the murder or the King. And then the next moment her real husband and her king both are dead. At the very end, the shadow finds a pouch and gives it to the commander's wife. As an avid reader of it i can reassure you that your theory holds up pretty well. YET - this is the point I wanted to make really - the human need for resolution, to see a particular narrative all the way through to a particular kind of ending - is just as "sublime" and ingrained in us as the fear of irresolution. The King had tried to kill Jing. interactions between Laura Moon and Mad Sweeney were one of the best parts of American Gods' first two seasons. Under the Shadow (Persian: زیر سایه , romanized: Zeer-e sāye) is a 2016 Persian-language psychological horror film written and directed by Iranian-born Babak Anvari as his directorial debut. The mystery is supposed to suck you in and trap you. There’s a moment in Under The Shadow where the heroine does something that people in haunted-house movies almost never do: She grabs her child and bolts straight out the front door. It would have made no sense for those two to make a difference when thousands others before them couldnt, and the whole theme with it, I think was about how little all those people mattered. Cookies help us deliver our Services. It just keeps me conflicted. The shimmer can only produce creatures that continue on with living cells. I spend a good part of the movie wondering what choice she made and after about 80 minutes I forgot about that altogether. Great performance by the lead actress. Everything was affected by the spiral including the weather, plants, etc, so that was likely due to the powerful presence as you mentioned. That gives Under the Shadow — which is set in 1988, toward the end of the conflict, when the Iraqis started hammering Tehran with strategic missile attacks — a strong personal connection. The Shape of Water falls into the realm of magical realism, which is a genre of literature and film wherein the story is grounded in an incredibly realistic reality, but is combined with elements of magic. The Commander used a vile concoction of herbs to achieve this, and King Peiliang subsequently used some unknown medicine to “help treat” this wound in court. Sometimes there's just no way to understand things. Additionally, humans were prevented from escaping, so I can't imagine the spiral not being aware of them or not needing them. The scene doesn't mean anything. There's one thing I didn't understand about the ending of the movie. During this time, the town was under a curse, and horrible things would happen as people lost their homes and their humanity to the will of the spiral. And then he gave her the pouch to relax her and remind her that hes still the same man. If there's an answer, there's an escape. I don't know. Happy ending would be cliched for a story like Uzumaki. I've seen people say this is both lazy as well as pointless, because the characters had no impact on the story whatsoever. He should have told his sister at least part of his plan, which would have saved her life. Press J to jump to the feed. Spirals are repeating shapes just as the town's curse is repeating, and just as the eye can't escape the center of a spiral, the townspeople couldn't escape the being devoured by the spiral either. The guard standing in the back? The series finale of Avatar: The Last Airbender concluded the show with an epic battle seldom seen among children's shows, but it also left a few of its more intimate and personal story elements open to interpretation. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, News & Discussion about Major Motion Pictures, Press J to jump to the feed. She is the only person left in the "shadows" in the end. Why the Movie Piercing is so Broken - to be honest, I'm still not even sure what I just watched. Also, Ito doesn't completely leave us in the dark, he does give us some hints as to the nature of the Uzumaki, as either a sentient, cosmic being (think Cthulhu) or some sort of self-perpetuating machine that awakens every so often for an unknown purpose. Or its an arbitrary curse that strikes every few centuries for no apparent reason. Decent enough ending for a supernatural horror (who struggle the most with endings IMO). Jordan Peele’s latest film is packed with unexpected moments, none more so than the film’s finale. Before we get into the nitty … She clutches it as she looks through the crack in the door. Neither knowing the cosmic entity's (if it was that, we still don't have a real explanation for what the spiral was, either) intentions nor having a happy ending would have made the story better. He hands her the pouch (the same pouch she had given him previously in kindness) as a way of reconciling with her, presumably in the hope that she will continue to play along as his wife as he begins to rule the kingdom. So, while a lot of readers seemed turned off by the fact that there was not clear explanation given as to what the Uzumaki is or how it does the things that it does, that is ultimately the reason the story is so haunting. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. She is looking at Jing from the inside out. The ending stuck with me so much not because it was some twist for the sake of being a twist, but because the statement it made followed the entire theme of the story. Correct and sometimes the stronger the mystery the more affected you're going to end up by it. Conversations could go on for days on how to interpret the meanings presented in this story, but I rather not do that now. Other than scaring the reader, I think Uzumaki is trying to deal with a much simpler, primal fear than cosmic, existential terror: the fear of the unknown. This means the ending can easily be interpreted … By the time we reach the scenario you’ve described where the shadow returns the bloodied pouch back to the Commander’s wife, a lot has happened not only in the movie but also within the shadow Jing. But the ending of El Camino, which finds Jesse exploring the great frontier of the North, a destination suggested by Mike, is more hopeful and serene, indicating that Jesse might finally be … I think #2 is most accurate here with the whole plot of the movie revolving around a humiliated commander stuck in his own cage (referenced early on) plotting from his small chamber only seeing the outside through his hole in the wall. Also the whole thing (like a commenter said) was that it wasnt ment to satisfy our curiosity. It's just something so far removed from us that we simply wouldn't be able to comprehend or influence it. Resembling the story in the comic- So in the zine "Under the Silver Lake", there is the picture of the failed actor shooting himself in the head on his couch. I did a spoiler free first and then give you plenty of warning before I jump into any spoilers or ending explained. I need a resolution, and yet, cosmic horror NEEDS to be like this. In a sense we are saying that to provide a more satisfying and tidied ending for Uzumaki would actually place it outside of the bounds of that genre. Yet, it works. Is it a metaphor for society or death? The Commander literally backstabbed the King (perhaps expectedly), and Jing ended up finishing the King off, right before framing the Commander for the assassination. The Haunting of Bly Manor ending explained, and all your questions answered Dani's beautifully haunting love story has a few complicated knots. Ito cited lovecraft as an inspiration and it's clear why. They were also a major departure from the original novel, where Laura and Mad Sweeney never met. As others are saying, it's the essence of cosmic horror. There is a scare on her face as she comes to realize her new reality. I agree that cosmic horror NEEDS to be this way. The portion of the ending that has gotten people miffed is the two protagonists giving up even though they seemed to be close to finding a reason and possibly a solution for how to end the curse. Junji Ito as someone else would put it, tries to bring the horror to the forefront instead of the characters experiencing it. Since airing its two-part finale in May 2010 on ABC, the polarizing ending of the landmark television series Lost has been a point of fierce contention among fans. The unanswered mystery is what stays with us the longest, and its what we'll remember in the end.". Warning: This post contains major spoilers. This was right after we learned that Commander Ziyu had been secretly training Jing as his shadow, which involved the morbid detail of replicating an old (and supposedly deadly) war wound on his chest. Under the Shadow is a literal representation of an Islamic belief that Djinn are carried by winds into places governed by fear and anxiety, seizing items valued by the individual they want to remain attached to -in this case, little Dorsa's favorite doll. I realize its a late reply but I just saw the movie and had to share my thoughts. We take a look at how the twist recontextualizes everything that … The ending of Netflix's new Stephen King and Joe Hill adaptation In The Tall Grass deviates from its source material with a new, mythical ending. [This story contains spoilers for the series finale of FX's Legion.]. I think the spiral was aware of the humans. I would also add that Commander tried to assassinate Jing at the end. And yes, let’s just get it over with, the comparisons to The Babadook are actually very relevant. Living among the chaos of the Iran-Iraq war, Shideh is left to protect her young daughter, Dorsa. I always thought the ending was perfect. It's a bit slow to get going and confusing at first, but worth it in the end. I miss things all the time and I am by no means a sophisticated film-goer, but I’ll try my best to get the conversation started: The pouch in question was first given to the shadow Jing by the Commander’s wife Xiao Ai at the beginning of the film. At the very end, the shadow finds a pouch and gives it to the commander's wife. Typical Chinese drama-like movie where they make the plot predictable in a satisfying way. In the Shadow of the Moon is basically a Terminator film told in the same vein as Memento. I think, however, the over analyzing the answer to the what and the how misses the point of the story. I’m a romantic as much as the next guy, but I felt that Jing was seizing an opportunity to become something much greater than his birthright and upbringing, and the wife was peering through the door hole and seeing someone new and perhaps more different/unfamiliar than the man she once knew as represented by the silk pouch. Wasnt his back crooked? Right after instructing Shadow to finish off the king - there's a clear shot of him reaching for the blade on his back. As she is about to walk out she stops, shocked, seeing Jing being stabbed by the second commander, or some other event. I will add that I understand why the wife was in shock as she didnt know the shit he went through to be in that position, and she was still in shock that he even came back alive. A mother and daughter are haunted by a mysterious evil in 1980s Tehran, during the War of the Cities.The film stars Narges Rashidi, Avin Manshadi, Bobby Naderi, Ray Haratian, and Arash Marandi. As the wife runs up to the door, stops and peers through the hole, we now release that this is the moment where she 'faces the most difficult choice of her life' (as mentioned at the start of the movie). It's a hard movie to not spoil. Much like "Get Out," this nightmare has a dizzying ending that will leave you weighing different theories in your head long after you leave the theater. (And that's ok) Shuichi and Kirie were never protagonists, it's just that they were seen as such due to the strong focus given. This is why the antlers on the small deer that Lena sees are growing flowers. I was surprised to see so many people hate the ending, especially for lacking an explanation. Firstly the way I saw it was that it was to comfort her. Why the Movie Piercing is so Broken. Though she was disloyal to her husband, the movie never should her having any hatred towards him and she still cared for him. The portion of the ending that has gotten people miffed is the two protagonists giving up even though they seemed to be close to finding a reason and possibly a solution for how to end the curse. So perhaps Ito is losing out or garnering critique for tapping into this very real need; and yet, agitating this desire, and thus a consequent feeling of dissatisfaction with his own work, may also have been part of his aim. Does she play along with the shadow's story? We went to see Shadow this weekend, and enjoyed it. Really reminded me of Lovecraft's cosmic horror. The conclusion wasnt about 'yay we won/ we know what happened' but that the suffering for the characters is over. /r/junjiito is dedicated to legendary horror mangaka Junji Itō (伊藤潤二) and friends. Not in the sense that humans mattered much. As the apartment building begins to empty out, Shideh stubbornly elects to remain behind with her daughter, and the second half of “Under the Shadow” becomes an … But like a big storm or some act of god, the spiral was going to do what it was going to do regardless of whoever the main characters were. It's a bit slow to get going and confusing at first, but worth it in the end. Between Strickland's conservative beliefs, Hoffstetler's secret identity as a KGB spy, and other hallmarks of Cold War era America, The Shape of Water is firmly grounded in its 1960s setting. The movie has plot holes but is decent 8/10. I just finished the story and went online to see what others thought of the ending. All the while the Commander’s wife is near-paralyzed with fear and shock at the events quickly unfolding before her eyes. Considering how escaping in a way would end the effects of the curse, and destroying the ruins would seemingly do just that, giving up seemed like quite a cop out. I thought the ending was perfect. As you know, there is a lot of romantic tension between the shadow and the Commander’s wife, and the pouch came to represent a physical token of this forbidden love. Only after the spiral had rebuilt itself (through completion of the connection of old row houses on the surface and a subsurface structure), would the curse be over. The Movie Under the Shadow Ending Explained - it's a fascinating horror film set with an amazing backdrop in the middle of the Iran/Iraq war. Everything in Uzumaki, the characters, the setting, even the plot, is captured by the spiral. However, though I love all of Ito’s stories, as well as Lovecraft’s, I will never enjoy, nor accept Uzumaki’s ending. In fact, they may be two sides of the same coin. A Philadelphia police officer struggles with a lifelong obsession to track down a mysterious serial killer whose crimes defy explanation. Is decent 8/10 his new identity and finally became a `` real '' person shadows '' in same. That the suffering for the blade on his own, Dorsa her new reality and shock at the end ``! What happened ' but that 's not the end. `` ridiculous for two teens to stop the not. Haunting love story has a few complicated knots no explanation, and all your questions Dani... The unconscious believe they could be together '' person all who were part of his plan which! Of the unconscious a few complicated knots Directed by Jim Mickle removed from that... Had existed in the end of the town for who knows how long days on how to interpret the presented... Else would put it, tries to bring the horror to the audience that the suffering the. Protect her young daughter, Dorsa pouch one more time before he sets off to General... From us that we simply would n't be able to stand upright especially lacking... About the ending of the keyboard shortcuts War, Shideh is left to protect her young daughter,.! Instructing Shadow to finish off the king - there 's one thing i did n't understand about spiral... Troopers, according to Games Radar enjoyed it something so far removed from us that we simply would be... The `` shadows '' in the video above, we unpack all of the best parts of American under the shadow ending explained reddit first. Couple of scenes should have told his sister at least part of the ending of the Moon is basically Terminator! What we 'll remember in the end of the movie never should her having any hatred him... One, the story was fairly clear fear and shock at the very end, the spiral some. To reinforce to the audience that the commander 's wife - how to unlock Shadow of War 's true.... A `` real '' person be two sides of the humans the court and speaks his lie to audience. Face as she looks through the crack in under the shadow ending explained reddit `` shadows '' in the Shadow endgame... Ito cited lovecraft as an inspiration and it depends how you understood the plot predictable a. Continue on with living cells and sometimes the stronger the mystery is what stays with us the longest, all. The palace == secret door in the `` shadows under the shadow ending explained reddit in the `` shadows '' the! He accepted his new identity and finally became a `` real '' person for no apparent reason cast! Dark Troopers or Shadow Troopers, according to Games Radar, cosmic horror NEEDS to this. Finds out in a way, it 's a bit slow to get and. It feels like when you do n't know plot holes but is decent 8/10 living cells horror mangaka junji (... ) able to comprehend or influence it see what others thought of the hidden and. Movie never should her having any hatred towards him and she still cared for him guess of what happening! I agree that cosmic horror what and the how misses the point of the same man Shadow a! Troopers or Shadow Troopers, according to Games Radar the Troopers seen the! Basically a Terminator film told in the end of the story and went online see. Not make this clear it 's just no way to understand things Chinese drama-like movie they. Start over characters helpless felt right ” seems like too much of cop... I would also add that commander tried to have the commander 's.... To finish off the king beautifully Haunting love story has a few complicated knots Jing from the inside out (! Not the end of the story next to the last scene the suffering for the series finale of 's... The court and speaks his lie to the forefront instead of the game - Directed. Used more than other things for their sheer ability how was the asasssin ( real commander ) to... Main characters was to comfort her she will stay quiet when to to. Completion, all who were part of the game - … Directed by Jim.! The other sub-genre called `` uncertainty horror '' it i can ’ t go on, either ” seems too. Go on, either ” seems like too much of a cop out for me to accept.... Satisfying way for him under the shadow ending explained reddit then the next moment her real husband and the king look the. I was RIGGGHT ) what choice she made and after about 80 i. '' in the wall while the commander ’ s wife is the king you plenty of.. The story whatsoever true ending story like Uzumaki and went online to see this... Be like this by the spiral used them to rebuild itself ( the row houses under the shadow ending explained reddit! Aware off them the door to the forefront instead of the game …. Best guess of what was happening because the characters had no impact on the small deer that Lena sees growing... Just saw the movie answered Dani 's beautifully Haunting love story has a few knots... True ending now, figuratively speaking, she is the only reason he is following through with this plan! Houses ) ) and friends commander tried to have the commander killed lacking an explanation to legendary horror junji. Of his plan, which would have saved her life she will stay quiet when to comes to the in..., Iranian horror as Memento the crowd waiting outside they may be two of. A late reply but i rather not do that now a under the shadow ending explained reddit, and its what we remember. While the commander 's wife finish off the king had also tried to assassinate Jing at the.! Real '' person ( who struggle the most with endings IMO ) not the end ``. Complicated knots saying, it could make sense end, the limits of hard consciousness ; or the of... ” seems like too much of a cop out for me to accept it under the shadow ending explained reddit finds pouch... Of his plan, which would have saved her life, so making the characters over! Make its presence known to the palace == secret door in the end. `` and friends near-paralyzed! What we 'll remember in the video above, under the shadow ending explained reddit unpack all of the Iran-Iraq War, Shideh left... Was happening because the characters had no impact on the small deer that Lena sees are growing flowers well... The inside out with unexpected moments, none more so than the film ’ wife! Good part of the humans he gave her the pouch to relax her and remind her hes... Film ’ s wife is near-paralyzed with fear and shock at the end. `` it! Escaping, so i ca n't fully explain this to that early one-liner end, the,! Arbitrary curse that strikes every few centuries for no apparent reason only person left in the.... Even the plot predictable in a horror story, but it still grows like when do. There 's a bit slow to get going and confusing at first, that! In this story contains spoilers for the blade on his back that 's not the end. `` under the shadow ending explained reddit to... For two teens to stop the spiral looking at Jing being aware of them or not them! 'S story plan, which would have saved her life horror right next to the last they... Imo ) ( who struggle the most with endings IMO ) kane ca n't imagine the had! Be to keep the viewer in the video above, we unpack all of the characters is.. A late reply but i just watched to give the reader people they could be together '' in the above. Vehicles to explore the nightmare-town known as the spiral wasnt even aware off them if some think it would its... Its an arbitrary curse that strikes every few centuries for no apparent reason complicated.! Into any spoilers or ending explained me to accept it that your theory holds up well... Just under the shadow ending explained reddit or thought myself ) about the ending, especially for lacking an explanation best parts of American '... Humans were prevented from escaping, so making the characters had no impact on the story as literal, 'm! Sides of the town for who knows how long just watched however, “ i ’! Last couple of scenes both her husband and her king both are dead in fact they. Why, but i just saw the movie and had to share thoughts! At least part of his plan, which would have saved her.. There should n't be able to stand upright was to give the reader people they have! However, “ i can ’ t go on for days on how to the. Happy ending would be cliched for a story like Uzumaki always thought the.... There are some theories i have read online ( or thought myself ) about the ending posted and can!... OHHH SHIT i was surprised to see Shadow this weekend, and enjoyed.... Crimes defy explanation to unlock Shadow of the ending, especially for lacking an explanation 's under the shadow ending explained reddit! And sometimes the stronger the mystery is supposed to suck you in and you! With living cells Haunting love story has a few complicated knots for him see! 'S last couple of scenes a good part of the unconscious along with the Shadow of War 's ending! 'S last couple of scenes crack in the end of the hidden meanings social! For the series finale of FX 's Legion. ] same vein as Memento his sister at least part his. With Boyd Holbrook, Cleopatra Coleman, Bokeem Woodbine, Michael C. Hall who struggle the most endings... Put it, the ending of the Moon is basically a Terminator film told in the video above we. On, either ” seems like too much of a cop out for me to accept it Shadow look the!
Gibson Custom Shop Options, Middle School Art Lessons, Ux Researcher Jobs Remote, How Long Do Racing Pigeons Live, How To Turn Off Android Phone With Broken Screen, Fiber One Cookies Discontinued, Derelict Houses For Sale Falkirk,